Regulatory Q&A Forum
Ask questions, share knowledge, and get help from the regulatory community
What are the most common reasons for an FDA RTA hold on an eSTAR submission?
The FDAโs electronic Submission Template And Resource (eSTAR) is designed to standardize 510(k) submissions, theoretically reducing the risk of administrative errors that can lead to a Refuse to Accep...
What biocompatibility testing is needed for a Class II 510k device?
When preparing a 510(k) for a medical device with patient-contacting components, such as a catheter made from a new polymer or a wound dressing with a novel adhesive, how should sponsors approach thei...
How do I choose the best predicate device for my 510k?
When preparing a 510(k) submission for a new medical device, such as a Class II diagnostic imaging software, sponsors often face a critical strategic decision: selecting the most appropriate predicate...
What is the FDA review timeline for a De Novo classification request?
For novel, low-to-moderate risk medical devices without a valid predicate, the De Novo classification pathway provides a route to market. A common point of confusion for sponsors involves projecting t...
What are the common mistakes to avoid in an eSTAR 510k submission?
The mandatory adoption of the electronic Submission Template And Resource (eSTAR) for 510(k) submissions was intended to streamline and standardize the review process. However, transitioning from trad...
What are the most common reasons for a 510k Refuse to Accept (RTA) hold?
When preparing a 510(k) submission for a Class II medical device, such as a new software-controlled infusion pump, what are the most common administrative and content-related pitfalls that lead to a R...
What are the most common reasons for a 510k Refuse to Accept (RTA) decision?
The FDA's Refuse to Accept (RTA) policy for 510(k)s acts as an initial administrative checkpoint, ensuring a submission is sufficiently complete to proceed to a substantive review. An RTA decision can...
How do I determine substantial equivalence for a 510k with no direct predicate?
What are the key components of a robust substantial equivalence argument when a new medical device lacks a single, direct predicate and must instead rely on multiple predicate devices? For instance, c...
Cruxi vs RegDesk vs Innolitics vs Essenvia: Which FDA 510(k) Solution Is Right for You?
I'm evaluating different solutions for FDA 510(k) submissions. How do Cruxi, RegDesk, Innolitics, and Essenvia compare? Which one is right for my stage, team, and budget?
Cruxi on Product Hunt
We just launched Cruxi on Product Hunt โ an AI copilot for FDA 510(k) submissions. For most early-stage medtech teams, the real pain doesnโt start with code or hardwareโฆ it starts when someone says: ...
Cruxi on Product Hunt
We just launched Cruxi on Product Hunt โ an AI copilot for FDA 510(k) submissions. For most early-stage medtech teams, the real pain doesnโt start with code or hardwareโฆ it starts when someone says: ...
How to get a small business discount for 510k FDA fees?
For a small medical device company preparing its first 510(k), understanding the FDA's Small Business Determination (SBD) program is crucial for managing submission costs. While the program offers a s...
What biocompatibility testing is needed for a Class II implant 510k?
For a Class II implantable device, such as a surgical mesh or orthopedic implant, establishing a clear biocompatibility testing strategy is a critical step in preparing a 510(k) submission. While cons...
How to write a substantial equivalence argument for a 510k submission?
When preparing a 510(k) submission, the central task is to demonstrate Substantial Equivalence (SE) to a legally marketed predicate device. While selecting a predicate with the same or a similar inten...
What level of clinical evidence is required for an FDA De Novo submission?
For a novel, low-to-moderate risk device, such as an AI-powered diagnostic software or a new therapeutic wearable, that has no legally marketed predicate device, how can a sponsor strategically determ...
What biocompatibility testing is required for a Class II implant device?
When preparing a 510(k) for a Class II medical device intended for long-term implantation, such as an orthopedic bone screw, how should a sponsor develop a biocompatibility testing plan that satisfies...
How long does the FDA 510k substantive review phase actually take?
Medical device manufacturers often use the 90-day MDUFA performance goal for 510(k) review as a key benchmark in their project planning. While this 90-day target is an important metric for the FDA, it...
What causes an FDA 510k Refuse to Accept (RTA) decision?
What is a Refuse to Accept (RTA) decision in the context of an FDA 510(k) submission, and what common administrative issues can trigger this outcome? An RTA decision is a determination made by the FD...
What are the most common reasons for an FDA 510k RTA refusal?
What are the most common administrative and content-related deficiencies that lead to a 510(k) submission receiving a Refuse to Accept (RTA) decision from the FDA? For medical device sponsors, particu...
How does an FDA AI request impact 510k review timelines?
When a sponsor receives an Additional Information (AI) request from the FDA for a 510(k) submission, how does this "stop-the-clock" event affect the total time to clearance? The standard FDA review g...